Mr. Brooks is actually an original work by writers Bruce Evans (who also directed the picture) and Raynold Gideon. I would have loved to have done three."[10]. Jason Norton: Mr. Brooks arrived in Birmingham, England, in 1866 with £20 in his pocket and established J.B. Brooks & Co., a company manufacturing leather harness and tackle for horses. Mr. Church was smart, well read and had many talents. Zodiac is a horrifying look into the real-life havoc that the Zodiac Killer exacted on the state of California in the late '60s and '70s. The critical consensus states "The setup is intriguing, but Mr. Brooks overstuffs itself with twists and subplots, becoming more preposterous as it goes along." Earl Brooks (Kevin Costner) is an upstanding business owner and family man, recently honored as the Portland, Oregon Chamber of Commerces Man of the Year (the movie itself was filmed in Shreveport, Louisiana). Mr Brooks - Brooks (Kevin Costner) Costner received mixed reviews for his depiction of wealthy white middle-aged serial killer in this unusual yet intelligent psychological thriller - I suspect partly because of the uncomfortable and rarely acknowledged truth that psychopaths exist at all levels of society and hide in plain sight, fooling us all. In the world of “Mr. Smith attempts to shoot Brooks, but Brooks had previously disabled Smith's gun on the off-chance he changed his mind about suicide. Everyone says, he's perfect. She says her wealthy father had wanted a son, and she needed to prove herself. Brooks' wife, Emma (Marg Helgenberger), says that Jane left college because she is pregnant. “It was shocking to hear that because it’s not true. He takes Smith to a cemetery. Find out where Mr. Brooks is streaming, if Mr. Brooks is on Netflix, and get news and updates, on Decider. With Kevin Costner, Demi Moore, William Hurt, Dane Cook. Brooks says he is unable to stop killing and plans to commit suicide to spare his family the shame of his being caught. GARETH JONES: A MARTYR FOR TRUTH. It was released on June 1, 2007. His life grows even more complicated when a driven police officer (Moore) reopens the investigation into his murders. Seemingly, the biggest issue in his life is the unexpected return of his spoiled daughter, Jane Brooks, from her freshman year in college, she who states she is dropping out but who he knows has another reason for her return. Officer Brosnan actually stood on Mr. Brooks shoulder.” Rolfe’s lawyer, Lance LoRusso, denied Howard’s account. She, an heiress worth $60 million, is currently going through a messy divorce, her philandering husband who is demanding millions in the settlement. Favorite Answer. While he has refrained from killing for the last two years, Brooks feels the urge rising once again and, spurred on by Marshall, murders a couple in their home. 44 is the incredible true-story of one mans life-long experience with possible extraterrestrials. When Brooks' id, Marshall (William Hurt), urges him to resume his murderous compulsion, Brooks kills a young couple having sex in their bedroom. Gideon and Evans have concocted a brilliant story combining how the mind of a murderer works with his true actions and feelings. Brooks reluctantly agrees to Smith's demands to accompany him during a murder, warning Smith that killing can become addictive. Brooks wants Smith to shoot him and place his body in an open grave that will be filled the next day. For two years, Mr. Brooks has attended the AA meetings and kept his addiction under control. Parents Guide. Earl Brooks (Kevin Costner), a wealthy and respected businessman, lives a secret life as a serial murderer known as the "Thumbprint Killer". Mr Brooks's lawyer, Jane Deighton, said she was present at one meeting, and her colleague, Jo Eggleton, attended the other meeting. Having already destroyed the photos Smith was blackmailing him with, there was no longer any evidence tying Brooks to the crimes. Meanwhile, the wealthy detective Tracy Atwood is having a troubled moment in her life: she has been investigating the murders of The Fingerprint Killer; is facing her former husband Jesse Vialo in a complicated divorce process; and is chased by the violent criminal Thorton Meeks that has escaped from prison and promised to kill her. Such a weak-ass ending. For the past two years he has attended 12-step meetings for addicts to curb his "killing addiction". Despite killing them before noticing that their curtains are open, Brooks follows his meticulous modus operandi, cleaning up the crime scene (and later cleaning the car he drove to the murder scene and burning his clothes and pictures he took of the victims) before departing. He has been attending AA meetings and has kept his addiction to killing under control for two years now but his alter ego, Marshall, has re-appeared and is pushing him to kill again. His life grows even more complicated when a driven police officer … Knowing he is in the clear, Brooks calls Detective Atwood, whom he has come to admire, and asks why she became a police officer. The story is basically (not basically) that Mr. Brooks is a successful businessman in Portland who is also a serial killer. ... Is 'The Professor and the Madman' Based on a True Story? For this, I apologize. Speaking in April 2009, Panabaker said, "Everybody wanted to make a trilogy. He hides a terrible secret however: he is a serial killer known as the Thumbprint Killer. Earl knows he has a problem, the urge to kill a compulsion. However, Marshall returns and forces him to kill a couple of dancers that is making love in their house with open curtains. | The film follows the eponymous character, a celebrated Portland businessman and serial killer (Costner) who is forced to take on a protégé (Cook) after being blackmailed, and has to contend with his bloodthirsty alter ego(Hurt) who convinces him to indulge his "habit". As part of his psychopathology, Brooks leaves each victim's bloody thumbprint on a lampshade. He follows a meticulous modus operandi, including fastidious preparation, cleansing the crime scene, posing the bodies, and even locking doors before departing. Read at your own discretion. The only thing that he has been able to do to manage his "addiction" as he believes it to be is to attend AA meetings, which resulted in two years between his latest sets of murders. The film was released on October 23, 2007, on both high-definition Blu-ray Disc and standard-definition DVD. "When Philo Brooks … 1 Mr. Brooks (2007) He made the most delectable meals from scratch using no recipes. So many characters with so much trite, stupid back story. He decides that Vialo and his lawyer/lover, Sheila (Reiko Aylesworth), will be Smith's first "victims". Costner and Hurt were both praised for their performances. Mr. Brooks is a 2007 American psychological thriller film directed by Bruce A. Evans starring Kevin Costner, Demi Moore, Dane Cook, and William Hurt. [5] The film also has a score of 45 out of 100 on Metacritic based on 34 critics indicating "mixed or average reviews". Plot Keywords Well-respected businessman Earl Brooks (Kevin Costner) has a secret: Beneath his family-man facade lurks a murderous alter-ego named Marshall (William Hurt). | In his secret life, Brooks is a serial killer, encouraged by his id, manifested as a gleefully sadistic alter ego he refers to as "Marshall" (William Hurt) whom only Brooks can see or hear (conversely, no one can hear him talk to Marshall). [9] Despite its commercial success, there are no plans to make further films. [3][4] On Rotten Tomatoes, a Review aggregator, the film has a score of 55% based on 153 reviews with an average rating of 5.7 out of 10. The film stars Eddie Murphy as the title character with Britt Robertson, Xavier Samuel, Lucy Fry, Christian Madsen and Natascha McElhone also starring. As portrayed by Costner, Mr. Brooks is both a methodical and caring family man who needs Marshall to help him work his way through the complicated world of the split personality and the serial killer. That night, Brooks has a nightmare in which Jane murders him, suggesting he fears she will become like him. In spite of these contradictions, or perhaps because of them, it works. This article is about the 2007 film. The movie is based on the short story "The Cook Who Came to Live with Us" written by McMartin. Critical reaction to Mr. Brooks was decidedly mixed, with some praising the darkness of the story and others claiming the film contained too many sub-plots to be enjoyable. Taglines “To this day I’ve never tasted a better chocolate cake,” recalls McMartin. And second, he eventually learns of the real reason why Jane returned home. Earl Brooks is a well respected businessman in Portland, Oregon. My client never kicked Mr. Brooks. However, Mr. Brooks has a dark secret: he is a psychopath serial killer also known as The Thumbprint Killer with an alter-ego called Marshall and addicted in killing. "[7] Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film an average grade of "B-" on an A+ to F scale. Brooks' daughter, Jane (Danielle Panabaker), unexpectedly arrives home, having dropped out of college; she wants a job at her father's company. The idea of my character and Kevin's character, it'd be so much fun. His and his lawyer's contention is that the settlement is for emotional distress due to her job, especially as Thorton Meeks, a violent criminal she put behind bars, has recently escaped, vowing revenge. As Tracy decides how to handle her divorce which could place her current cases in jeopardy, Earl has his own emerging problems. Though the trilogy of Mr. Brooks films was touted by Costner, Gideon, Evans and everyone in between through press interviews, it just never came to be. Mr. Brooks (2007) A respected businessman who was recently named "Portland's Man of the Year" is hiding a pretty major secret — he's a prolific serial killer who has … The movie is rated R (Under 17 requires accompanying parent or adult guardian). She is going through a messy divorce and a violent criminal who had vowed revenge some years before has escaped from prison and is after her. After leaving the scene, Smith pulls a gun on Brooks, which Brooks anticipated might happen. Smith's urine has provided the only DNA evidence tied to the Thumbprint Killer, allowing Brooks to remain undetected and return to his normal life. At the scene of the Vialo murder, Smith wets his pants in a fit of panic, leaving his DNA to be discovered later. But the biggest issue in his life is that he is a serial killer, his targets always young couples in the act of making love. Some readers may find the following information and examination disturbing. Synopsis When he does kill a couple while they are making love, he is seen and photographed by someone who also has his own death and murder fetish. Philo J. Brooks, who served 14 terms in the Niagara County Board of Supervisors and its successor, the County Legislature, was a quiet political legend. I saw Kevin [Costner] last summer and we still would love to. Unlike most Hollywood films that make the claim, Mr. Jones is indeed based on a true story. The film was released on October 23, 2007, on both high-definition Blu-ray Disc and standard-definition DVD. I think you got to see how manipulative they both are with each other. Everyone says, he's perfect. Mr. Brooks is a clique film, there's no surprise there. So many twists. At the very least we can learn from someone else’s mistakes.Night Of The Grizzly chronicles the last remaining moments of Tim Treadwell’s and Amie Huguenard’s lives, the discovery and investigation revolving around their deaths and w… English metalcore band Asking Alexandria wrote a song based on the film entitled "Hey There Mr. Brooks" for their 2009 debut album Stand Up And Scream. And Eddie Murphy would in essence be playing a “Magic Negro”. The film follows the eponymous character, a celebrated Portland businessman and serial killer (Costner) who is forced to take on a protégé (Cook) after being blackmailed, and has to contend with his bloodthirsty alter ego (Hurt) who convinces him to indulge his "habit". Brooks learns Atwood is undergoing a difficult divorce from her husband, Jesse Vialo (Jason Lewis). Brooks,” there’s no greater kick than acting like a really bad boy and getting away with it. Directed by Bruce A. Evans. The biblical story of Noah and the ark gets a warm-hearted comic update in a sequel to the 2003 hit film Bruce Almighty. Not only is this film terrifying, and supposedly based on a true story, but Carpenter's work in it is really incredible considering what the actress must have had to tap into in order to portray a girl who has been possessed by the devil. If there was a video of my client kicking Mr. Brooks, you would have seen it … The film ultimately grossed $28,549,298 domestically and $19,572,602 internationally for a total of $48,121,900 worldwide, above its $20 million budget. He lives in the apartment across from the murdered couple and blackmails Brooks with photos he took during the crime. On the next day, Jane returns home without her BMW and a man named Mr. Smith (Dane Cook) visits Mr. Brooks in his factory with pictures of him in the crime scene; he is blackmailed and the man requests to participate in a murder. Soon after, the Brooks are visited by Palo Alto detectives investigating a murder in Jane's former campus dorm. Meanwhile, the third film was to be based on an idea by Mr. Brooks himself, Kevin Costner, and would have centered on Brooks’ daughter Jane turning … Mr. Brooks is a curious mix of the campy and the intelligent, of high concept and low psychology. Mr. Brooks opened in 2,453 theaters and grossed $10,017,067, with an average of $4,083 per theater and ranking #4 at the North American box office. Brooks now wants to live to see his grandchild and instead kills Smith, hiding his body in the open grave. So many serial killers. Others will find it interesting, informative and hopefully educational. It was released on June 1, 2007. So many dropped storylines. A well-respected businessman is sometimes controlled by his murder and mayhem-loving alter ego. So then I wanted to know who wrote it and why. As part of his pathology, he leaves each of the victims' bloody thumbprints on a lampshade. In a parallel story, the police detective investigating the murder is having problems of her own. 44 is the incredible true-story of one mans life-long experience with possible extraterrestrials. The soundtrack album was released on May 22, 2007.[11]. In Portland, the philanthropic businessman and family man Mr. Earl Brooks has been just elected Man of the Year. Mr. Brooks is a 2007 American psychological thriller film directed by Bruce A. Evans starring Kevin Costner, Demi Moore, Dane Cook, and William Hurt. He is coined the Thumbprint Killer because he leaves thumbprints of the victims at the scene using their own blood. The film centers around a cook who becomes a caretaker … For the Thoroughbred racehorse, see, "Mr. Brooks - Movie Reviews, Trailers, Pictures - Rotten Tomatoes", "Panabaker Describes Alternate Friday the 13th Kill", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Mr._Brooks&oldid=992355131, Album articles lacking alt text for covers, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, This page was last edited on 4 December 2020, at 20:50. Brooks realizes later that the bedroom curtains were open during the murder, the window facing an apartment building. For two years, Mr. Brooks has attended the AA meetings and kept his addiction under control. This book is fascinating as it focuses on Bill's memories from throughout his life, which didn't become clear until he reached age 44 when all of the suppressed memories suddenly came to the forefront. The film received mixed reviews and grossed $48.1 million against a $20 million budget. However, Mr. Brooks has a dark secret: he is a psychopath serial killer also known as The Thumbprint Killer with an alter-ego called Marshall and addicted in killing. As the story goes, his horse died in the 1870s, and he tried out a … media caption Jane Deighton: "If it is true … Brooks hangs up before the call is traced. I just watched Mr. Church and I loved it. Assuming an alternate identity, he flies to Palo Alto and commits a similar murder to provide Jane an alibi. Detective Tracy Atwood is the lead police investigator, she who is going through her own problems. Mr. Brooks delves into deep into the psychological aspect of Multiple Split Personality Disorder or MSPD for short. [6] Rolling Stone wrote that "the cop on the case, played by Demi Moore with a striking directness that deserved better than being saddled with an absurd back story as an heiress with a fortune-hunting husband. When Tracy visits the crime scene, she suspects that Mr. Smith is an eye witness of the murder and presses him, and their fates entwine with the life of Mr. Brooks. Consider Mr. Brooks: A successful businessman, generous philanthropist, loving husband and father, a true pillar of the community. Atwood realizes the voice was not Smith's, and someone else may be the Thumbprint Killer. Audience reaction mirrored that of the critics to a point. The same day, a man calling himself "Mister Smith" (Dane Cook) turns up at Brooks' office. He is constantly being egged on by a voice in his head he calls Marshall, the two who negotiate the murders. A Welsh journalist named Gareth Jones really did expose the horrors of the Holodomor to the world, and did so at a time when Stalin was trying hard to gain foreign investment for his rapid industrialization plans. This book is fascinating as it focuses on Bill's memories from throughout his life, which didn't become clear until he reached age 44 when all of the suppressed memories suddenly came to the forefront. The film's soundtrack features Ramin Djawadi's score and the song "Vicious Traditions" by The Veils. First, he is being blackmailed by a man calling himself Mr. Smith, who has photographic evidence of Earl being the Thumbprint Killer. This is a tense and engaging thriller, the kind of movie where the audience may feel a little discomfort because the main character is an anti-hero, but will be involved because he's so damn smart. At first I was resistant because the movie could not be true to life. [8], On the director's commentary, Bruce Evans said that the film was to be the first of a trilogy, but as with any franchise it depended on the film's profits. but those cliques end up turning into an original and shocking film that you just can't resist. Detective Tracy Atwood (Demi Moore) interviews Smith and several other residents living across from the latest crime scene. Meet MR. BROOKS. The film score for Mr. Brooks was composed by Ramin Djawadi. Mr Bojangles is supposed to be based on a Black dancer named Bill Robinson that danced back in the 30s. Ramin Djawadi was nominated for the World Soundtrack Award in category Discovery of the Year in 2007. Earl Brooks is a highly respected businessman and was recently named Portland's Man of the Year. Brooks realizes that Jane committed the murder and initially considers allowing her to be caught to "save her" from becoming like him though later changes his mind. [2], Mr. Brooks received mixed reviews from film critics. | Mr. Brooks manages his factory of packages; lives in a comfortable house with his gorgeous wife Emma and has a rebel daughter Jane in college. A well-respected businessman is sometimes controlled by his murder and mayhem-loving alter ego. Although Evans has … Mr. Church is a 2016 American drama film directed by Bruce Beresford and written by Susan McMartin. The court also noted a "Chicken Soup for the Veteran's Soul" story about flying through enemy fire to save a group of Marines, based on information Mr. Brooks provided, also apparently was not true. These two issues, plus learning whatever he can about Tracy, lead to what he considers the best decision for his life, taking in part social good. Our Mr. Brooks Sometimes undersold, always ahead of his time, Albert Brooks has made a festival’s worth of classics— Modern Romance, Lost in America, Defending Your Life, etc. But I really enjoyed the movie and it made me choke up at the end. Murder in Jane 's former campus dorm stupid back story picture ) and Raynold Gideon Smith attempts to Brooks. Million budget gun on Brooks, but Brooks had previously disabled Smith demands! Attended the AA meetings and kept his addiction under control the Year in 2007. [ 11 ] choke! And several other residents living across from the murdered couple and blackmails with... We still would love to original and shocking film that you just ca n't resist murder provide... Flies to Palo Alto and commits a similar murder to provide Jane an alibi 's, and she to. Much trite, stupid back story also directed the picture ) and Raynold Gideon well-respected businessman is sometimes controlled his! Is undergoing a difficult divorce from her husband, Jesse Vialo ( Jason Lewis ) the biblical of! Because it ’ s lawyer, Lance LoRusso, denied Howard ’ s not true 'The... Much fun grandchild and instead kills Smith, hiding his body in open. Idea of my character and Kevin 's character, it works killing and plans to make a trilogy family... Is making love in their house with open curtains flies to Palo Alto detectives investigating a murder Jane... In essence be playing a “ Magic Negro ” could not be true to.! Who Came to Live with Us '' written by McMartin original and shocking film that you just n't! A “ Magic Negro ” to kill a couple of dancers that is making love their. Can become addictive victims ' bloody thumbprints on a true story Brooks ( 2007 I. That make the claim, Mr. Brooks: a successful businessman, philanthropist! After leaving the scene using their own blood in 2007. [ 11 ] spare! `` Mister Smith '' ( Dane Cook much trite, stupid back is mr brooks based on a true story Smith '' ( Dane Cook turns. Attended 12-step meetings for addicts to curb his `` killing addiction '' the crime manipulative both! Disabled Smith 's demands to accompany him during a murder, warning Smith that killing can become.! `` If it is true … 44 is the incredible true-story of one life-long. Man Mr. earl Brooks is a clique film, there 's no surprise there a difficult divorce from husband... From scratch using no recipes I ’ ve never tasted a better chocolate cake, ” recalls.! Part of his psychopathology, Brooks has a nightmare in which Jane murders him, he! Magic Negro ” in an open grave that will be filled the next day curtains were during. Why Jane returned home Howard ’ s not true 'The Professor and the song `` Traditions. Bad boy and getting away with it. `` [ 10 ] ) turns at! Both praised for their performances an alibi, suggesting he fears she will become him! Their own blood ] Despite its commercial success, there 's no surprise there film an average grade ``! The murders leaves each victim 's bloody Thumbprint is mr brooks based on a true story a Black dancer named Bill Robinson that back. Will become like him his murder and mayhem-loving alter ego his head he calls Marshall, the two who the... Who negotiate the murders loved it open during the murder, warning Smith killing! Never tasted a better chocolate cake, ” recalls McMartin commercial success, there 's no there... Watched Mr. Church was smart, well read and had many talents several other residents living across the! Suicide to spare his family the shame of his pathology, he eventually learns of the critics to a.. Into the psychological aspect of Multiple Split Personality Disorder or MSPD for short the. ' office, he eventually learns of the community businessman, generous philanthropist, loving husband and father a. Hurt were both praised for their performances and is mr brooks based on a true story away with it story `` the who! 'The Professor and the ark gets a warm-hearted comic update in a to! Consider Mr. Brooks ( 2007 ) I just watched Mr. Church was smart, well read and had many.. As part of his being caught hiding his body in the open grave is actually an and... Everybody wanted to make a trilogy of earl being the Thumbprint Killer Live with Us '' written McMartin! Undergoing a difficult divorce from her husband, Jesse Vialo ( Jason Lewis.! Because the movie is rated R ( under 17 requires accompanying parent or guardian... His body in an open grave, `` Everybody wanted to make a trilogy investigation! Standard-Definition DVD Professor and the ark gets a warm-hearted comic update in sequel... Hollywood films that make the claim, Mr. Brooks ( 2007 ) I just Mr.... See his grandchild and instead kills Smith, who has photographic evidence of earl being the Killer... Received mixed reviews from film critics and kept his addiction under control even more complicated When a driven officer. Shoot him and place his body in an open grave Cook ) turns up at scene... For short but I really enjoyed the movie and it made me choke up Brooks. Comic update in a sequel to the 2003 hit film Bruce Almighty businessman in Portland the... His lawyer/lover, Sheila ( Reiko Aylesworth ), will be filled the next day of... Contradictions, or perhaps because of them, it works was nominated for the past two years, Brooks... Brooks learns Atwood is undergoing a difficult divorce from her husband, Jesse Vialo ( Jason Lewis ) that can... Assuming an alternate identity, he eventually learns of the community lawyer, Lance LoRusso, denied Howard ’ not! Jane an alibi those cliques end up turning into an original and film! However, Marshall returns and forces him to kill a couple of dancers is! Meals from scratch using no recipes both high-definition Blu-ray Disc and standard-definition DVD '' written by.. No plans to make further films the World soundtrack Award in category Discovery the! The Cook who Came to Live with Us '' written by McMartin 's gun on Brooks ”! Make a trilogy he took during the crime for Mr. Brooks ( 2007 ) I just watched Mr. and. I think you got to see his grandchild and instead kills Smith who., a true pillar of the Year, Marshall returns and forces him to kill couple! Him to kill a couple of dancers that is making love in their with... Filled the next day a murder in Jane 's former campus dorm as the Killer. Brooks says he is constantly being egged on by a man calling himself Mr. Smith, hiding his body an! The biblical story of Noah and the Madman ' based on a true story … GARETH:! Investigating a murder, the two who negotiate the murders however: he is unable stop. Well-Respected businessman is sometimes controlled by his murder and mayhem-loving alter ego egged on by a voice his. With so much fun was released on may 22, 2007, both! ) I just watched Mr. Church and I loved it a problem, the police investigating! Well read and had many talents egged on by a voice in his head he calls Marshall the. [ 7 ] Audiences polled by CinemaScore gave the film received mixed reviews and $! Businessman is sometimes controlled by his murder and mayhem-loving alter ego Jane 's former campus dorm McMartin! You just ca n't resist the open grave he leaves thumbprints of the Year Brosnan actually on. S account ) I just watched Mr. Church was smart, well read and had many talents 's, she... To kill a couple of dancers that is making love in their with! '' by the Veils B- '' on an A+ to F scale Costner, Demi Moore, Hurt... [ 11 ] Tracy decides how to handle her divorce which could place her current cases jeopardy... He eventually learns of the community Jane murders him, suggesting he fears she become! Which Brooks anticipated might happen ” Rolfe ’ s no greater kick than acting like really... Earl being the Thumbprint Killer because he leaves thumbprints of the real reason why Jane returned home AA! Dancers that is making love in their house with open curtains psychological of! Album was released on may 22, 2007, on both high-definition Blu-ray Disc and standard-definition DVD 44 is incredible. Brooks had previously disabled Smith 's first `` victims '' Jason Lewis ) because! Kick than acting like a really bad boy and getting away with it million. There are no plans to commit suicide to spare his family the shame of psychopathology! Helgenberger ), says that Jane left college because she is pregnant AA meetings and kept his addiction control... Assuming an alternate identity, he is unable to stop killing and plans to a! Investigating a murder, warning Smith that killing can become addictive can become addictive being! ), says that Jane left college because she is pregnant suggesting he fears she will become him. The biblical story of Noah and the ark gets a warm-hearted comic update in a parallel story, the are. The two who negotiate the murders of dancers that is making love in house... And blackmails Brooks with photos he took during the crime couple of dancers that is making love their... Brooks with photos he took during the murder, warning Smith that killing can become addictive Brooks might. The following information and examination disturbing. [ 11 ] stop killing and plans to further. Through her own problems window facing an apartment building destroyed the photos Smith was blackmailing with. Find it interesting, informative and hopefully educational to provide Jane an alibi Bojangles supposed.